American Idol Top 16 – Girls

Katie – I think Katie took the advice of a younger song but then she “elevator-ed” it.  Meaning, she toned it down so much that it sounded like elevator music.  That song is supposed have spunk and she had none of that.  Plus, she just didn’t hit the notes right.  I’m not too disappointed because she hasn’t been in my Top Pick list.

Siobhan – Wow.  That was just awesome. Classy.  Current.  Powerful.

Lacey – I felt like that was an improvement on last week for sure.  But with a sleepy song like that, she’s going to have a hard time being memorable.  I really think Lacey will be amazing recorded with a good producer.

Katelyn – Three words into her song and I want it off.  Darn. And she did so well last week.

Didi – Wow, a TON better than last week but that wasn’t great for me.  What did the judges hear that I didn’t??  I mean, I like the girl.  I WANT her to do well.  But it just didn’t do it for me.

Paige – Wow, something did not go right tonight.  She was either super nervous or super emotional tonight.  Seems like she was really holding back.  Bless her heart.

Crystal – The beginning was really, really weak.  I didn’t like the different arrangement.  She seemed to save it though.

Lilly – Not my very favorite performance of hers but I still liked it.  I think she pulled it off.

Favorites: Siobhan and Crystal

Not making the Top 12: Katelyn and either Paige or Didi.  Paige may make it through if people split their vote between Didi and Lacey.

Check out Boomama for more!